Barry HarrisThe method
8.4

Playing with the familySwapping and chaining related dominant scales

Once you know a dominant’s family, you can play any relative over it (over C7: E♭7, F♯7 or A7) and run the four related dominant scales into each other. Barry wanted these pairings practised, and had a reason for each.

In plain words

The four dominants of a family share one diminished chord, so Barry used them in each other’s place. Over E♭7 he would play A7; while the pianist played B♭ minor to E♭7, he ran E♭7 into A7. Asking a pianist for a C7, he had him hold just two notes of it and set A, C and E♭ triads on top: that, he said, is family.

Bird’s D7 line on Indiana2:54Tritone lines on Indiana and Embraceable You0:00Jazz theory, part 3: four dominants from one diminished9:109:4410:15

He also wanted the four run into each other, and each pairing has a use. E♭7 into C7 is how he plays G half-diminished to C7, since E♭7 holds the G half-diminished. C7 into A7 covers E half-diminished to A7. E♭7 into F♯7 takes you into the tritone of C7, which he said starts another thing altogether. If you can’t run A7 into C7 and back, he told a class, you aren’t practising the music.

Student performances and coaching34:2434:5935:3136:0536:38

Other pairs have their own reasons. Barry linked B7 into D7 to a ii going to a iv minor, which he heard in When Sunny Gets Blue; B7 into F7 is the tritone pair. Horn players especially should practise these, he said: a pianist can play the chord and hear the outside sound, but a horn player has to learn it without hearing the harmony underneath.

Bird’s D7 line on Indiana3:304:034:375:13

Step by step

  1. Over one dominant, any of its three relatives fits: over C7, use E♭7, F♯7 or A7 lines. With chords, keep two notes of the dominant and put a relative’s triad on top.

    A triad over C7
    𝄞♯
    1. A
    2. C♯
    3. E
    C triad over C7
    𝄞
    1. C
    2. E
    3. G
    E♭ triad over C7 (add E next to the E♭)
    𝄞♭♭
    1. E♭
    2. G
    3. B♭

    Bird’s D7 line on Indiana2:54Jazz theory, part 3: four dominants from one diminished9:1010:15Triads in the dominant family0:03

  2. Run one dominant scale into another of its family, choosing the pair for the progression: E♭7 into C7 for G half-diminished–C7; C7 into A7 for E half-diminished–A7; or into a tritone (E♭7 into F♯7, the tritone of C7; A7 into E♭7), which Barry said starts something else altogether.

    Student performances and coaching35:3136:0536:38Howard Rees, Chord Explorations ¶42

  3. The switch need not fall on the barline: because the scales are so close, you can start a phrase on one and finish it on another.

    Howard Rees, Chord Explorations ¶14Howard Rees, Chord Explorations ¶41

How he said to practise it

  • Run the four dominant scales of a family into each other, in both directions: A7 into C7 and C7 into A7, A7 into E♭7, E♭7 into C7, F♯7 into E♭7.

    Student performances and coaching34:2436:05

  • Know why you are running each pair, not just how: Barry asked his class why he would run E♭7 into C7, then showed it over G half-diminished.

    Student performances and coaching34:5935:31

  • Horn players: practise B7 into D7 and B7 into F7, and try a relative over a written dominant (A7 over E♭7, then on into D7), learning them even without the chords sounding underneath.

    Bird’s D7 line on Indiana2:544:375:13

In Barry’s words

Each one plays from the moment he says it. Every other moment he teaches it is listed below.

If you don’t know how to run A7 into C7 or C7 into A7, then you aren’t practicing the music.

Student performances and coaching, New York City, 2004. Master class with student players, on the family of the B♭ diminished chord 34:24 Watch on YouTube at 34:24

Why would I run... [E♭7] into C7? You got to know why.

Student performances and coaching, New York City, 2004. Before showing E♭7 into C7 over G half-diminished 34:59 Watch on YouTube at 34:59

There’s a family, a family of four... The children play with each other first.

Student performances and coaching, New York City, 2004. After running E♭7 into the tritone, F♯7 36:05 Watch on YouTube at 36:05

There’s a reason for you practicing the four sevens to go together.

Bird’s D7 line on Indiana, The Hague, 1989–98. After trying A7 over E♭7 and running it into D7 3:30 Watch on YouTube at 3:30

Where this comes from

Everything above is drawn from these. Open any one to check it.

Every moment he teaches it11 moments in 6 recordings

Each time opens the transcript there; the video plays when you are online.

Student performances and coaching

New York City, 2004 — 45 min On YouTube

  1. 34:24

    Run A7 into C7 and back, or you aren’t practising the music; names the B♭ diminished family.

    Watch on YouTube at 34:24

  2. 35:31

    Plays G half-diminished as E♭7 into C7, then E♭7 into F♯7, the tritone.

    Watch on YouTube at 35:31

  3. 36:05

    The family of four plays together first: A7 into E♭7, E♭7 into C7, F♯7 into E♭7, C7 into A7.

    Watch on YouTube at 36:05

Bird’s D7 line on Indiana

The Hague, 1989–98 — 6 min On YouTube

  1. 2:54

    Over E♭7 he plays A7, then tries running the A7 into D7.

    Watch on YouTube at 2:54

  2. 3:30

    Reasons for practising the four sevens together; B7 into D7 and When Sunny Gets Blue.

    Watch on YouTube at 3:30

  3. 4:37

    Horn players should practise B7 into D7 and B7 into F7, without hearing the chords.

    Watch on YouTube at 4:37

Tritone lines on Indiana and Embraceable You

The Hague, 1989–98 — 6 min On YouTube

  1. 0:00

    Over the pianist’s B♭m7–E♭7, a phrase that runs E♭7 into A7.

    Watch on YouTube

Jazz theory, part 3: four dominants from one diminished

New York City — 12 min On YouTube

  1. 9:10

    Two notes of C7 with family triads (A, C, E♭) above: ‘that’s family’.

    Watch on YouTube at 9:10

  2. 10:15

    Put E next to the E♭ so it sounds dominant, not minor 7th; then resolve to F major.

    Watch on YouTube at 10:15

Triads in the dominant family

1 min On YouTube

  1. 0:03

    Short clip: just play the A triad, the C triad, even the E♭ over C.

    Watch on YouTube at 0:03

Introducing the sixth diminished scale

The Hague, 1989–98 — 27 min On YouTube

  1. 13:41

    D7’s relatives F7, A♭7, B7: their triads sound right with the chord because family.

    Watch on YouTube at 13:41

From the lessons2 lessons, 5 points

Notes taken from Barry’s classes, each tied to the moment it comes from.

Swapping dominants within the family

  1. Idea

    Barry called the minor third the most important interval of all. Major thirds are good too, since the whole-tone scale is built from them, but the diminished chord gives you minor thirds. The major keys C, E-flat, F-sharp and A are brothers and sisters, one family: C’s family includes E-flat, E-flat’s includes F-sharp, and so on.

    Jazz theory, part 1: key families a minor third apart4:58

  2. Idea

    Barry treated E-flat 7 and C7 as one family: E-flat 7, he said, stands for C7, and when he plays a half-diminished he plays E-flat 7 to C7, because E-flat 7 gives the G half-diminished. He also linked C7 and A7 to E half-diminished. From the E-flat 7 he went into F-sharp 7 to get into the tritone, which he said starts something else altogether. The four dominants of a family, he said, play with each other first.

    Student performances and coaching35:1836:06

Practise the four related dominants as a family

  1. Exercise

    The four dominant chords that come from one diminished chord are, Barry said, like brothers and sisters who grow up together, so practise them together. Learn to run A7 into C7 and back, E-flat7 into C7, F-sharp7 into E-flat7 and so on, connecting each pair in the family. He said that if you can’t run these into each other, you aren’t practising the music right.

    Student performances and coaching34:0235:1836:06

  2. Idea

    Barry said you have to really learn about tritones, and that there are reasons for practising the four sevens together, and first; each pairing has its own reasons. He linked B7 into D7 to a ii going to a iv minor. His example was Sunny Gets Blue in E: the first chords are F-sharp minor to B7, and the tune then goes to A minor 7, a iv minor. Horn players especially, he said, should practise B7 into D7, and also B7 into F7.

    Bird’s D7 line on Indiana3:304:034:37

  3. Exercise

    When you practise B-flat7 into E-flat major, also practise E7 into E-flat major, treating the E7 as the most important chord rather than the B-flat7. A pianist has an advantage: he can play F minor 7 to B-flat7 and then the E7 and hear the outside sound. A horn player has to practise these resolutions without really hearing them.

    Bird’s D7 line on Indiana4:375:135:47

In writing7 notes

What his interviews, his students’ class notes and other teachers’ articles add.

How other teachers explain it10 videos, 11 series episodes

Barry’s students, and their students, teaching it their way. A second opinion, not Barry.

In the teaching series

Episodes on this idea in the long series by other teachers. Each name opens that whole series in order.

Read further5 links

These open on the web.

Free to read

Books and paid courses